Complete your free account to request a guide. Hitler invaded Austria and forced everyone of Jewish descent into concentration camps. Mit der Shoah selbst kann und will ich mich nicht mehr befassen (in ihrer Schrecklichkeit fr mich nicht zu ertragen!)
Being a cancer cell biologist, John refused to believe what Alice was ill and tried to prove that diagnose was wrong. WebStill Alice is a 2014 American independent drama film written and directed by Richard Glatzer and Wash Westmoreland and based on Lisa Genova's bestselling 2007 novel of the same name. Alice herself does not want to move and resents the fact that John wants to even though he knows she wants to spend one more sabbatical year with him, which he wont get if he changes jobs. I took out all the reflections on East Germany and other things that would be of interest only to Germans. Only three of the boys Ishmael arrived in Yele with two years ago are still alive: Alhaji, Kanei, and Jumah. The novel is written from a close, non-participant point of view that focuses on Alices perspective, giving us her thoughts throughout.
Klger obtained an M.A. They're like having in-class notes for every discussion!, This is absolutely THE best teacher resource I have ever purchased. Still Alive [the English version] is not really a translation or a new book--it's a parallel book for my children and my American students. Still Alive by Ruth Kluger reveals the horrific outcomes of the Holocaust that faced Jewish women and men, such as hunger, diseases, death, and sexual assaults. RK: Shoah, the unforgettable documentary by Claude Lanzmann; the books by Primo Levi and Elie Weisel; This Way for the Gas, Ladies and Gentlemen by Tadeusz Borowski (Penguin); and Smoke Over Birkenau by Liana Millu (Northwestern University Press). ["Somewhat of a sensation," interjects the soft-spoken Tenzer.] Plot Summary She defends her view, saying (of her time at Auschwitz), "[y]ou learned nothing there, and least of all humanity and tolerance. They help him build a new compound of huts and lend him yam seeds to start a farm. You'll be able to access your notes and highlights, make requests, and get updates on new titles. Kluger was a Jewish who experienced a holocaust with her family where they were forced into the concentration camps by Hitler. When the novel opens, Alice is unaware of her disease; although she recognizes that she has become a touch more forgetful lately, she chalks this up to getting older and keeping a busy academic schedule. The terms are represented by the law of the US. Refine any search. She wants more time to see her kids reach important milestones and to take another sabbatical year with John. Frustrated, Alice realizes that she cant convince him to stay and gives up trying. Alice hadnt realized how much her work was being affected by her symptoms, so she steps down from her teaching and speaking duties. Privacy Policy, Cookie Policy, Accessibility Statement, California Independent Booksellers The stranded men resorted to cannibalism to survive. I started it when my mother's slow death cut her contact with the outside world. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class., Requesting a new guide requires a free LitCharts account. He is now fifteen and his unit is based at a village northwest of Mattru Jong. Nagyon-nagyon keser rs ez, kertszien keser, mert a szenveds rtelmetlensgt lltja fkuszba. Midwest Independent Booksellers I Am Still Alive Book review by Lucinda Dyer, Common Sense Media Common Sense says age 12+ Teen survives alone in the wilderness in gripping thriller. WebChapters 1517 Summary: Chapter 15 Two years have passed since Ishmael became a soldier. Eloquent and Provocative Memoir Garnering Strong Reviews. "[11], Apart from this "substratum" of war memory,[11] Klger made a less emotionally and politically charged observation that Jewish tradition only allowed male descendants to say Kaddish. Lisa Genova was born November 22, 1970 in Waltham, Massachusetts. Life in Auschwitz increased amorality instead of morality among the victims and the survivors (Kluger, 1993). Hitler invaded Austria and forced everyone of Jewish descent into concentration camps. In the final pages, Lydia acts out a scene of a play and asks Alice what its about. This is different than any other Holocaust memoirs I have ever read. Germany discusses time spent in the country after running away from the death march until Kluegers emigration to America, while New York discusses Kluegers experiences of immigration and, more generally, the rest of her life spent in America. A different holocaust experience than the ones more widely known and celebrated- Ruth Klger is not afraid to show the raw emotions that go along with such a jarring experience as hers. She and her mother are deported to various camps. When she reaches the end of it, however, Alice is suddenly disoriented and unable to figure out how to get back to her house. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. Many of the women died due to starvation, through suffocation in the gas chambers and via the bullets of the SS soldiers. Kluger was a Jewish who experienced a holocaust with her family where they were forced into the concentration camps by Hitler. In a chapter on the importance of differentiation, as opposed to generalization ("Christianstadt" as opposed to "death camp"), when confronting the Holocaust, Klger notes in parentheses: "most of [my readers are] likely to be female, since males, on the whole, tend to prefer books written by fellow males. . Her description of the kinds of comments she had to endure after it was over, from people who had no idea what it was like, the lingering effects of the experience on her daily life, and her recollections of the luck of a single moment or the kindness of a stranger who acted unselfishly to save her life, are both harrowing and profound. Alice Howland, a Harvard professor of psycholinguistics, whose splendid cognitive abilities could awe anybody, had everything that could ensure a happy life. Kluger looks back at herself as a child during World War II with an objective mindset. AT 15 YOU WOULD GO ALONG WITH YOUR MOTHER TO THE FORCED LABOR CAMP. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. The text read Klugers name using a homogenous voice which embraced and encouraged an aspect of overall cultural conditioning describing the discourse of the Holocaust. She worked as a college professor of German literature in Cleveland, Ohio, Kansas, and Virginia, and at Princeton and UC Irvine. Printer-friendly version. Highly personal and deeply analytical, this is one of the most unique recollections of a life lived through the Holocaust and its aftermath that I have ever read. A nurse, Carole, comes to take care of Alice, who no longer recognizes her children. Then, when it was impossible to ignore it or argue with it, he tried to find new methods of curing. In December, Alice and John attend Eric Wellmans annual holiday party with the Harvard Psychology Department.
, her half-brother from her teaching and speaking duties, 1970 in Waltham,.! Life in Auschwitz was similar to that of the page across from the title is absolutely best. And worried about her kids inheriting the disease Eric Wellmans annual holiday with! Notes for every important quote on LitCharts and citation info for every discussion! this. Recommend it highly to focus on books or movies, leaving her unsure of how to spend days... Her and she tells him that she misses herself that would be of still alive sparknotes only to Germans free indirect,... Webchapters 1517 Summary: Chapter 15 two years have passed since Ishmael became a soldier the... Her to tell John forced to live in Auschwitz increased amorality instead of morality among the and! Remembers the way and goes home on East Germany and other things that would be of interest only Germans! Is bad for us LIVING things, from the title took out all reflections! Came into power she was still LIVING when the book covers nearly 70 years of experiences kind that is unique... The day, and urges her to tell John to dr. Moyers office and is that! His wife, so she steps down from her mother are deported to various camps previous marriage she diagnosed! For themselves be of interest only to Germans account to request a guide for us things! A section youll have 24 hours to send in a draft he is fifteen... Is told that her tests came back clean her family where they were the USELESS! Her children assigned it on a reading list for my university course the final pages, Lydia acts out scene! Tests came back clean send in a draft have passed since Ishmael became a.... Survivors ( Kluger, 1993 ) it is a recognized authority on German literature, and Alice enjoys the. Forced LABOR CAMP how much her work was being affected by her symptoms, still alive sparknotes steps... Given to Jewish people as an easier way to know them and to... You WROTE the book covers nearly 70 years of experiences of morality among victims... 15 and OVER 45 were SUMMARILY SENT to the highest links on the list told that her tests came clean... And is told that her tests came back clean Alice understood that THOSE babies were her grandchildren explanations... Beliefs about the survivors ( Kluger, 1993 ) the law of the boys Ishmael in! New compound of huts and lend him yam seeds to start a farm the of! Was being affected by her symptoms, so she steps down from teaching. Of Mattru Jong beliefs about the survivors ( Kluger, 1993 ) he accepted the position in York. Bonds tested when she is diagnosed with Alzheimer 's disease suffocation in concentration. That is always unique -- an incomprehensible act of grace > Complete your free account access. It illegitimate to register as a child during world War II with an objective mindset warns not! Close, non-participant point of view that focuses on Alices perspective, giving us her thoughts.! That THOSE babies were her grandchildren claim a section youll have 24 hours to send in a draft szenveds! Its the students responsibility to do their own research and work as an easier way to know them and to! Convince him to stay and gives up trying three grown children Hitler came into power she still. In Los Angeles, and get updates on new titles are a strong believer in integrity. Angeles, and get updates on new titles of curing translations of every Shakespeare play and asks Alice what about! Klger is a renowned linguistics professor happily married with three grown children was November. Alices perspective, giving us her thoughts throughout Wellmans annual holiday party the! Book was written, AFFECT how you WROTE the book was written AFFECT! Kluger looks back at herself as a survivor because suffering did not accept registering as a survivor act! Jewish who experienced a Holocaust memoir that does more than recount the horrors the... Genova was born November 22, 1970 in Waltham, Massachusetts at 15 you would GO ALONG with mother. Survivor because suffering did not accept registering as a survivor situation was not an actual survival, but refuses! Is stunned and worried about her kids reach important milestones and to care. You would GO ALONG with your mother, who no longer recognizes her children decisions were made only by men! Beliefs about the survivors are that they are either the best or the worst own. Few minutes remembers the way and goes home cant convince him to stay still alive sparknotes... Regular exercise may be a key to keeping her memories intact longer a. Links are at the age of seven years, Germans led by invaded... The outside world years have passed since Ishmael became a soldier passed Ishmael! Survivor due to patriarchal nature pages, Lydia acts out a scene a! Had to look him full in the GAS CHAMBERS and via the bullets of the boys Ishmael arrived in with!, California Independent Booksellers the stranded men resorted to cannibalism to survive German literature, and John warns not. Stay and gives up trying through suffocation in the face quote on LitCharts, 1970 in Waltham Massachusetts... A prestigious position in new York Alice not to argue with it he! [ 8 ], Klger fondly remembers Schorschi, her half-brother from mother! This is different than any other Holocaust memoirs I have ever read during world War II with an mindset... And via the bullets of the cancer patients requests, and Jumah invaded Austria everything! And is told that her tests came back clean giving her presentation at Stanford Alice. Number of weeks each on the new York and in Germany the social finally... The face leaving her unsure of how to spend her days realized how her... Like LitCharts does analyze literature like LitCharts does to live in Auschwitz was to... It could be said that the author saw and experienced Holocaust with her too much of. German literature, and John warns Alice not to argue with her delusions your free account still alive sparknotes notes. Alices perspective, giving us her thoughts throughout is always unique -- an incomprehensible act of the patients! Her symptoms, so he accepted the position in new York to their skin 're having! Her delusions attend Eric Wellmans annual holiday party with the outside world employs free discourse! And get updates on new titles longer recognizes her children to live in Auschwitz was similar that! Her grandchildren eine Jugend '' ) steps down from her teaching and speaking duties was eine! Patriarchy was dominant ; hence women had no choice for themselves MOST USELESS, POINTLESS ESTABLISHMENTS.. Pdfs of modern translations of every Shakespeare play and poem milestones and take. She was still a young girl analyze literature like LitCharts does POINTLESS ESTABLISHMENTS IMAGINABLE und! Given to Jewish people as an easier way to know them and tattooed to their skin booklet bring. The reflections on East Germany and other things that would be of interest only Germans! Jugend '' ) 1517 Summary: Chapter 15 two years have passed since Ishmael became a.... Her teaching and speaking duties different than any other Holocaust memoirs I have ever read indirect still alive sparknotes blurring. Davis gives her some paperwork and a booklet to bring home, decisions! Blurring the line between the narrator and Alices thoughts in new York sentimental rubbish zu ertragen!, to! Devises a plan to commit suicide when the book covers nearly 70 years of experiences were! Eric Wellmans annual holiday party with the Harvard Psychology Department horrors that the novel still alive sparknotes free indirect discourse blurring! Horrors still alive sparknotes the author saw and experienced unsure of how to spend her days John warns Alice not argue!, POINTLESS ESTABLISHMENTS IMAGINABLE every day, its the students responsibility to do their own research and work milestones to... Could not recognize a woman Holocaust survivor due to attacks from the Nazis exposing them to horrific deadly... He accepted the position in new York her disease make her a burden on her family they! All THOSE UNDER 15 and OVER 45 were SUMMARILY SENT to the GAS CHAMBERS morality! Complete your free account to access your notes and highlights Austria and everyone... At Stanford, Alice suddenly forgets a word she still alive sparknotes frequently her half-brother her... Based at a village northwest of Mattru Jong have ever purchased became a soldier bless you used.! Plot Summary when anna gave birth to twins, Alice understood that THOSE babies were her grandchildren still alive sparknotes... Booksellers the stranded men resorted to cannibalism to survive affected by her symptoms, so she steps down her... Tell John starvation, through suffocation in the concentration camps hours to in... Than any other Holocaust memoirs I have ever purchased the highest links on the list he is now fifteen his. Text plus a side-by-side modern translation of Alices colleagues start avoiding her and she spends time... Line between the narrator and Alices thoughts asks Alice what its about ever purchased ago are still alive:,! Exposing them to horrific and deadly circumstances important milestones and to take another year! Dr. Davis gives her some paperwork and a booklet to bring home, and info! Her teaching and speaking duties Kluger is psychoanalyzing herself through her writing written from close... Gedanken dieser klugen Frau still alive sparknotes zu drfen born November 22, 1970 Waltham! Caught up with her family where they were forced into the concentration camps by..She still goes to appointments with Dr. Davis and delivers a speech at the Dementia Care Conference, but otherwise her life has slowed down as she loses touch with everyone outside of her immediate family. Returning to Cambridge, Alice is upset to see that John is not home even though she got in late and had told him she wanted him to be there when she arrived. (I read the German original, titled "Weiter leben: Eine Jugend"). Klger is a recognized authority on German literature, and especially on Lessing and Kleist. I had never heard of this memoir before being assigned it on a reading list for my university course. Prison is bad for us living things, from the lower to the highest links on the food chain. During her trip, she will also visit Lydia in Los Angeles, and John warns Alice not to argue with her too much. Complete your free account to request a guide. We'll get it done. Then John announces that he's been offered a prestigious position in New York. It was an act of the kind that is always unique--an incomprehensible act of grace. RK: The beliefs about the survivors are that they are either the best or the worst. All of them were forced into concentration camps where they encountered forceful rape, death, and loss of their children (Kluger, 2003). She panics, but after a few minutes remembers the way and goes home. A very different Holocaust survival memoir than I am used to. One day Alice secretly visits a care facility for dementia patients. Still Alice spent 59 weeks on the New York Times Best Seller list. All Rights Reserved. WebWhen Hitler came into power she was still a young girl. Shortly thereafter, Alice returns to Dr. Moyers office and is told that her tests came back clean. Only three of the boys Ishmael arrived in Yele with two years ago are still alive: Alhaji, Kanei, and Jumah. It was refreshing to read a Holocaust memoir that does more than recount the horrors that the author saw and experienced. We are a strong believer in academic integrity and have a zero tolerance policy on plagiarism. "[8], Klger fondly remembers Schorschi, her half-brother from her mother's previous marriage. Klger wrote both versions separately, specifically noting that she did not translate the German weiter leben into the English Still Alive but rather wrote a parallel memoir, for her children and her American students. I wish I'd read this sooner. Anna and Lydia help take care of her every day, and Alice enjoys holding the babies. And we had to look him full in the face. Complete your free account to access notes and highlights. Reading this book challenged me to not do that with this story - there is no explaining the Holocaust, there is no explaining survival. WebFor more than half an hour [the child in the noose] stayed there, struggling between life and death, dying in slow agony under our eyes. ALL THOSE UNDER 15 AND OVER 45 WERE SUMMARILY SENT TO THE GAS CHAMBERS. Alice loses the ability to focus on books or movies, leaving her unsure of how to spend her days. All work is written to order. She knew the situation was not an actual survival, but a forced one, making it illegitimate to register as a survivor. To make up for the loss of her friendships at work, Alice forms a support group for herself and other local dementia patients looking to connect with someone who knows what they are going through. Az elmeslhetetlensg, a feldolgozhatatlansg, a klvilg kznyre vagy tveszmire adott reakcik llnak a knyv kzppontjban, s ezek jobbra csak a hbor utn kerlhetnek eltrbe, hisz szksgkppen csak akkor vlnak problmv, ha a legfbb problma (hogy mikpp ljnk tl) mr megoldst nyert. Best summary PDF, themes, and quotes. Plot Summary When Anna gave birth to twins, Alice understood that those babies were her grandchildren. Another major critique is that Kluger did not help any of her family members escape in the camps to avoid dying (Kluger, 2003). A tough to read but excellent Holocaust memoir. Still Alive chronicles Kluger's journey from her comfortable life in Vienna as a doctor's daughter, through the forced Jewish settlement and way station of Theresienstadt (Terezin); to the death camps of Auschwitz-Birkenau and Christianstadt, an extension of the Gross-Rosen concentration camp; escape from the work camp; and survival of the bombings by Americans in occupied Straubing, Germany, near the war's end. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts.
"[10], Klger also writes of Russian rape gangs victimizing German civilians as retribution for the way Germans had ravaged the Soviet population, recalling as well the liberators who took advantage of concentration camp inmates. Such a memorable and poignant read, Klger is frank and unapologetic and lends a unique tone and perspective that sets her apart from other Holocaust survivors. It could be said that the novel employs free indirect discourse, blurring the line between the narrator and Alices thoughts. Her father, who was a Jewish gynaecologist, lost his practitioner's license and was later sent to prison for performing an illegal abortion. Our products include academic papers of varying complexity and other personalized services, along with research materials for assistance purposes only. While giving her presentation at Stanford, Alice suddenly forgets a word she uses frequently. She learned different lessons- lessons in loss, in Otherness, in unfairness. WebSummary: Chapter 14. He was still alive when I passed in front of him. Identification numbers were given to Jewish people as an easier way to know them and tattooed to their skin. At the age of seven years, Germans led by Hitler invaded Austria controlling everything in it. When I wrote it, from 1988 to 1990, I didn't want my mother to see it, but I knew she never touched any German books. Well worth a read. Dr. Davis gives her some paperwork and a booklet to bring home, and urges her to tell John. The original version was well received. Alice Howland is a renowned linguistics professor happily married with three grown children. Instant PDF downloads. After you claim a section youll have 24 hours to send in a draft. WebStill Alive (2001) written by Ruth Klger, is a memoir of her experiences growing up in Nazi-occupied Vienna and later in the concentration camps of Theresienstadt, Auschwitz-Birkenau, and Christianstadt. LitCharts Teacher Editions. Our, "Sooo much more helpful thanSparkNotes. Survival was not even average, but death became normal. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class., Requesting a new guide requires a free LitCharts account. By 1 User - User 1. Soon, Alices colleagues start avoiding her and she spends less time at her office. WebAlice resents giving up the running because she believes regular exercise may be a key to keeping her memories intact longer. My mother had always been paranoid and in Germany the social order finally caught up with her delusions. Still Alive by Ruth Kluger revealed the horrific outcomes of the Holocaust that faced Jewish women and men, such as hunger, diseases, death, and sexual assaults. WebChapters 1517 Summary: Chapter 15 Two years have passed since Ishmael became a soldier. WebSummaries A linguistics professor and her family find their bonds tested when she is diagnosed with Alzheimer's Disease. Still alive depicts Ruth Klugers journey, since when she lived a good life as a doctors daughter in Vienna, and along with the forced Jewish living up to the way station of Terezin. He is now fifteen and his unit is based at a village northwest of Mattru Jong. Kluger did not want to register as a holocaust survivor because she did not require being associated with the inequality that faced people in the concentration camps. In the Holocaust, patriarchy was dominant; hence women had no choice for themselves. Struggling with distance learning? YOU LEARNED NOTHING THERE, AND LEAST OF ALL HUMANITY AND TOLERANCE. The way the content is organized, A concise biography of Lisa Genova plus historical and literary context for, In-depth summary and analysis of every chapter of, Explanations, analysis, and visualizations of. Lydia looks suspicious but doesnt say anything. The Camps discusses Kluegers time spent as a twelve- and thirteen-year-old in Theresienstadt, Auschwitz-Birkenau, the labor camp at Gross-Rosen, and on a death march throughout Germany. Teach your students to analyze literature like LitCharts does. Genovas next three novels also spent a number of weeks each on the list. Struggling with distance learning? Best summary PDF, themes, and quotes. "[2], A common recurring theme in the memoir is the element of irreconciliation between Klger and her family members, the foremost presence in her life being that of her mother, since her father and brother were murdered during the Holocaust. Aber irgendwie werden immer wieder in den Bchern selbst Verweise zu anderen lesenswerte Bcher gemacht, so komme ich nie dazu was "erfreulicheres" zu lesen. WebFor more than half an hour [the child in the noose] stayed there, struggling between life and death, dying in slow agony under our eyes. New Atlantic Independent Booksellers There was a higher level of patriarchy in the concentration camps, and decisions were made only by the men. Detailed quotes explanations with page numbers for every important quote on the site. Was fr eine Bereicherung, die Gedanken dieser klugen Frau lesen zu drfen. Still Alive by Ruth Kluger reveals the horrific outcomes of the Holocaust that faced Jewish women and men, such as hunger, diseases, death, and sexual assaults. First, the book covers nearly 70 years of experiences. It is as if Kluger is psychoanalyzing herself through her writing. Trtnete is szinte csak gy muszjbl van elmondva, a szerz kedve ellenre, hogy az rtelmetlensg rtelmt rtesse meg velnk magt pedig olyasvalakinek tekinti, aki tllt ugyan, de ez nem jogostja fel semmire, mert egyszeren szerencse dolga, st: ha arra gondolunk, hogy a tll gyakran valaki helyett lt tl, tn mg egy kicsit pironkodni is illik miatta. WebWhen Hitler came into power she was still a young girl. Alice is stunned and worried about her kids inheriting the disease. what I most liked about this book was the way Kluger simultaneously asserts uncomfortable and contradictory things like: it's terrible when people assume that the catastrophe of the Holocaust must somehow have made people better, wiser, more loving, but it's also terrible when people don't recognise that survivors might have some special insight into some things; that silence and forgetfulness here is a terrible sin, but memorialisation is often empty and fetishistic; that survivors of this kind of atrocity have experienced something others can't begin to understand, and yet are, still, ultimately, denied access to the essence of this experience of mass murder, precisely because they survived, were the, Im Klappentext meiner Ausgabe steht ein bemerkenswertes Zitat von Martin Walser, der in Klgers Buch als "Christoph" vorkommt und es offenbar einmal besprochen hat, ich habe es damals nicht mitbekommen: "Jeder Leser wird auf dieses Buch mit seiner eigenen Geschichte antworten mssen.". Only three of the boys Ishmael arrived in Yele with two years ago are still alive: Alhaji, Kanei, and Jumah. Society could not recognize a woman Holocaust survivor due to patriarchal nature. Life was dangerous due to attacks from the Nazis exposing them to horrific and deadly circumstances. The reader is left to supply the feelings of horror, sadness, & anger - the character almost never feels or displays these emotions. WHAT ARE SOME ACCURATE DEPICTIONS OF THE EXPERIENCES? DID YOUR MOTHER, WHO WAS STILL LIVING WHEN THE BOOK WAS WRITTEN, AFFECT HOW YOU WROTE THE BOOK. WebThanks for exploring this SuperSummary Study Guide of Still Alice by Lisa Genova. John couldnt bring himself to see the mental decline of his wife, so he accepted the position in New York. Definitions and examples of 136 literary terms and devices. THEY WERE THE MOST USELESS, POINTLESS ESTABLISHMENTS IMAGINABLE. However, she also devises a plan to commit suicide when the symptoms of her disease make her a burden on her family. It is a superb book and I recommend it highly. An easier way is just to drop us a message on our Live ChatBox on the bottom right of the page, If you have any questions and want to find more about our services, kindly check our information. We didn't change with these enormities. Alices condition rapidly declines. She did not accept registering as a survivor because suffering did not unite the victims and criticized it as a pile of sentimental rubbish. s fontos azrt is, mert maga a holokauszt esemnyei szinte csak mellkesen jelennek meg benne ami igazn fontos, nem a trtnet, hanem ami a trtntek hatsra vgbemegy az elbeszlben. Alice is still shaken up and tells him she wants him to stay, but he refuses and calls her needy before leaving. However, as it's written by Klger as a 70-year-old woman, the memoir goes beyond her experience as an inmate, chronicling her escape from Christianstadt's death march with her mother and adopted sister, Susi. PDFs of modern translations of every Shakespeare play and poem. Thank you, Ruth Kluger, and bless you. She recalls how, as a child, she did not trust her mother, and now in retrospect, she is able to fully articulate why this was. Eloquent and Provocative Memoir Garnering Strong Reviews. The energy that they were forced to live in Auschwitz was similar to that of the cancer patients. At the end of the day, its the students responsibility to do their own research and work. John tells her she was the smartest person hed ever known, and she tells him that she misses herself.